Chocolate Pecan Pie

November 12, 2008



A few of you keen-eyed readers guessed that yesterday’s final “teaser” photo was of pecan pie.  But since I’m not particularly a “pie person” to begin with (I’ve posted about only one other pie in over a year on this blog–and it wasn’t even my own recipe!), and since I most definitely AM a chocolate person, I decided that my pecan pie had to include chocolate.  

Besides, La Martha’s mini-mag, Everyday Food, featured in its latest issue a recipe for chocolate pecan pie, and I’d been yearning for it ever since I saw the recipe. It looked gooey, yummy, decadent, festive, and very, very chocolatey.  Staring at the photo simply made me drool.  It was one heck of a perfectly baked, perfectly decorated, perfectly chocolatey Perfect Pecan Pie.

So I set about creating my own (sugar-free, wheat-free, vegan) version of this masterpiece.  The magazine’s photo was soooo enticing: meticulously arranged pecan halves baked into a slightly bubbly, sticky, engulfing ebony base of glossy chocolatey deliciousness.  I had to have that pie!

The only other pecan pie I’ve ever made was another vegan rendition, from my friend Caroline Dupont’s cookbook, Enlightened Eating.  I began with her suggestion to combine maple syrup and barley malt syrup, then played with the other elements to come up with what I thought a good approximation of Martha’s confection.  I fluted the pie crust, poured in the filling, popped it in the oven, and waited.

Remember those old sitcoms where the inept housewife (choose your favorite:  Lucy, Edith, Peggy, Marge) attempts to do the laundry for the first time, and ends up using about 4,576 times too much detergent?  And then the machine starts to rumble and wobble, and a stream of soap suds bubbles up over the washer’s lid and glides along the front of the machine and down to the floor, eventually making its way across the room in one massive, seething wave of froth? 

Well, that’s sort of what the top of this pie looked like after 30 minutes in the oven. The chocolate mixture bubbled and heaved and puffed like the contents of a witches’ cauldron. firstpie2 The lovely fluted crust was coated in a gleam of dark, gooey, chocolatey filling, as were a few spots on the bottom of the oven.  All my perfectly placed pecan halves had been bobbing about in the foaming liquid like castaways afloat on the ocean, tossed this way and that,  messing up my beautiful, decorative arrangement entirely.  While it ended up tasting good, the pie looked horrendous.

For the second attempt, I used less filling and didn’t worry about perfectly placed pecan halves; I simply chopped them coarsely and folded them right into the filling.  Once again, there was a filling explosion that overtook crust, pie plate, and oven.  Curses!

Finally, it occurred to me:  let’s just take another look-see at Martha’s ideal recipe, why don’t we?  The pecans in her photo remained perfectly in position, nary a drop of filling even touching their sides.  On second thought, they were too perfect (sort of like Martha herself, no?): they were pristine and unscathed in their nakedness.  I re-read the recipe, and came upon this throwaway instruction:  “The pie filling puffs up dduring baking but settles as it cools.” AHA! Clearly, the photo did not represent this reality; like most food-styled pictures, this one had been assembled after the pie was baked, the raw pecan halves carefully placed atop an already-cooled pie!  Clever, Martha; very clever.

Well, if you can’t beat ’em, I say, then do them one better.  I revamped the recipe completely so that a pre-baked crust is subsequently filled with an unbaked filling.  Once the filling rests securely in the crust, then top with your perfectly formed, deliberately placed pecan halves, as decoration.  I proudly held up the finished product for the HH’s approval.  He took one look at my painstakingly positioned pecan halves and remarked, “It looks vaguely insectoid, don’t you think?”  Hmm. 

Despite the nutty carapace, this pie was heavenly.  Keep it cold for a dense, thick, toffee-like filling; or bring to room temperature for a softer, more gooey result.  Either way, it’s one perfectly baked, perfectly decorated, perfectly chocolatey Perfect Pecan Pie.

With its glossy, black, rich chocolate filling, I thought this would be the perfect submission to this month’s Sugar High Fridays, the event started by Jennifer, The Domestic Goddess, and this month hosted by Susan at The Well Seasoned Cook.  The theme this time round is “All That Glitters.” 

Chocolate Pecan Pie


pecanpieslice6Thick, rich, and toffee-like, this slightly non-traditional pecan pie is great for a holiday (or just your everyday) table. 



45 Responses to “Chocolate Pecan Pie”

  1. shellyfish Says:

    Never before have I so cursed my inability to find coconut oil…Pecan pie was one of my childhood favourites!

  2. coulditbeseitan Says:

    Oooooh! This is like Kentucky Derby pie! I love how healthy your ingredient list is – I’m definitely going to try this one. Maybe for Thanksgiving!

  3. Vegetation Says:

    My husband is mad for pecan pie, for me, the addition of chocolate would be perfect!

    And congratulations for being so persistent, it certainly paid off with a beautiful and delicious looking pie. I have a tendency to get cranky when things don’t work out and start throwing things around my kitchen in a huff, never to attempt the recipe again 😛

  4. Sue Says:

    Mmmm Ricki, another post to make my mouth water first thing in the morning! Now my usual oatmeal doesn’t seem quite so appealing… perhaps I’ll put some pecans in it, mmm and maple syrup… ok, sorry but I have to go…

  5. johanna Says:

    it already looked good but I was excited when I read it was a chocolate pecan pie – would you believe that the only time I have made pecan pie it was chocolate pecan pie – deliciously gooey and filled with lots of unhealthy stuff – I love your photos – looks wonderfully decadent!

  6. VeggieGirl Says:

    You totally just made ME a pie person now 😉

  7. Shelby Says:

    I’m not a pie person but I think I can make an exception for this!

  8. Now you’ve got me feeling all confident about baking a pie. We’ll see…this one looks great. And just wondering, why the spelt instead of wheat?

  9. Ah, Lucy. How I love Lucy!
    Your pie looks amazing, and not insectoid… unless you find insects delicious! 🙂

  10. Courtney Says:

    Holy Moly–that looks and sounds amazing! And I am not even a fan of pie…but I HAVE to make this. Soon!

    Thanks for sharing!

  11. Andrea Says:

    You make me want this pie even though I don’t like sweets with nuts! The filling sounds so good (except for those darned pecans!)Maybe I’ll make it anyway – to share. I wish I were a tester!

  12. Lisa Says:

    Just gorgeous Ricki. And I love the addition of maple syrup in the crust. I will try your pastry for sure, though I don’t make pie very often.

  13. Lisa Says:

    Wow. That would turn even me into a pie person! That is beautiful!!

  14. You’ve been tagged… check out my blog! 🙂

  15. Diann Says:

    Oh, boy, what a gorgeous pie. A gorgeous chocolate pie! Thanks for the recipe. It looks so easy and way better than Martha’s.

  16. Ricki Says:

    I’m pretty sure you could just use Earth Balance if that’s something you have/use. Or any other pie crust, really!

    Thanks for your comment, and for visiting! I’ve heard of Kentucky Derby pie, but didn’t realize this was it! And I actually had Thanksgiving in mind for this baby (even though ours happened last month) 🙂

    I’m like you about most things, but something about baking just gets my curiosity going, and I end up tweaking the same recipe over and over until I’m happy with it. For me, that’s fun! (weird, I know. . . )

    It does taste decadent, but in fact is waaaay healthier than “real” pecan pie!

    I use spelt and other non-wheat flours for everything, ever since I was diagnosed with a wheat sensitivity in 1999. I’ve come to love spelt (way more than wheat!) and find that things made with wheat taste kind of bland to me now.

    Aww, thanks! I bet this would be fine w/o the nuts as well, just a little more gooey. Or you could fold in something else you like, such as roasted pumpkin seeds, or how about some raisins or dried cranberries? Hmmm. . . I’m getting some ideas here. . . !

    It is pretty easy–and wow, I think I’ll email your comment to Martha’s site! 🙂

  17. ttfn300 Says:

    Wow… i’ve only ever had pecan pie once. But this makes me want it twice 🙂

  18. giz Says:

    Oh My Gawd!!!I personally don’t care if it looks like a witch’s cauldron. Pecan pie is my ultimate best of the best mostest (donja love my grammah?) favourite evahh!!! It would so be #1 on my stressbuster list. You have no idea how much I could use it today. AND…you’ve mixed it with chocolate…I hate you, I love you…I’m sooo confused.

  19. looks ridiculously yum!!!

  20. melody Says:

    You have WAYYYY outdone yourself! between this pie and your last post.. holy moly!

  21. Why are you tempting me with all these dessert photos?! You are mean! (But I will forgive you if you send me a slice of pie!)

  22. Celine Says:

    it looks like magic!

  23. holler Says:

    Lovely! I admire your tenacity in trying the recipe several times to perfect it.

  24. Ricki Says:

    Welcome to my world.

    Any time! Now, how do I mail it? 😉

  25. BitterSweet Says:

    Oh my god, that looks AMAZING. Seriously. I want this at my Thanksgiving table now!

  26. Pearl Says:

    Hi there! Your pecan pie looks amazing! I’ve been following your site for quite some time and finally started my own, so was hoping to add you! I’m not that much of a pie kinda girl, but your pecan pie is BEAUTIFUL! my mom would love it!

  27. Alisa Says:

    Ah, the deception! That looks so good, I may just have to give it a whirl. I love that you used cashew butter in it, yum. My vote would be for cold, sounds soooo good!

  28. Ricki Says:

    Thanks for your comment, and thanks for visiting! Glad you like the look of the pie. I think your own version on your blog is pretty cool, too 🙂

    It’s more like a candy when cold, more like a traditional pecan pie texture at room temp. Either way, I’m having a hard time not eating it. 😉

  29. Joanna Says:

    wow that looks amazing. do you know is spelt flour is gluten-free?

    i used it months ago, but lately haven’t been using flours with gluten. i’d love to try this out.

  30. Monica Says:

    I made this yesterday night. It is super fast to make and only takes one pan! Can’t get much better than that! Of course I did put the filling in a premade graham crust because I am lazy like that. This recipe is not overly sweet which I think health concious people would like. However, I made it for some non-vegan friends and it didn’t go over so well. It is the perfect recipe for something that is not over poweringly sweet, but might not be a good ‘conversion’ type recipe. Thought I would share.

  31. Ricki Says:

    Thanks for your comment! No, spelt flour is NOT gluten-free. It has about 30% less gluten than wheat flour, which is why I can eat it (and why it’s my most-used flour). I find the taste and texture closest to wheat of all the “alternative” flours.

    Thanks so much for your comment, and for visiting! Glad you liked the ease of preparation :). I had to smile at your comment about the sweetness, as I found this extremely sweet! I guess my taste buds have finally changed after all these years without refined sugar 😉 What was it your friends didn’t like about it?

  32. Mmm…I’m a sucker for pecan pie, which was my grandmother’s specialty! Thanks for the comment on my random things, so funny that we have so much in common!

  33. Vegan_Noodle Says:

    Chocolate pecan pie is one of my favorites! I love the look of the nuts in your piece of pie. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe!

  34. Lucy Says:

    Oh, yum.

    You see, who needs animal products when something as beautiful as THAT pie – oh, that pie! – can be made without.

    Oh, yum.

  35. Mansi Says:

    wow! I wish all holiday treats were as guilt-free as this one! looks fab Ricki!

    if you don’t mind, this would also be perfect for the vegetarian thanksgiving recipe event on my blog!:)

  36. megan Says:

    my mom always makes pecan pie for the holidays, but i have never been a very big fan (who in the world knows why!) but i bet if she tried this recipe with the chocolate, i would be able to eat the whole thing! sounds great!

  37. Lisa Says:

    I do love pecan pie and chocolate. I made a pecan pie of my own last week with a chocolate layer in the bottom. Of course mine was loaded with sugar! How clever of you to make one without! And the outcome is beautiful…

  38. Pilar Says:

    Wow, this is really good looking! I have some pecan nuts that are going inmediately for baking this.
    Regards from Spain

  39. Maris Says:

    This sounds so good! Tomorrow is my mom’s birthday and I want to bring home a nice dessert – this might be a winner!

    Thanks for stopping by my blog! Let me know if you try the pumpkin scones, how they turn out 🙂

  40. KTangers Says:

    I tried your recipe yesterday and it was really delicious! Thanks for sharing. Chocolate Pecan Pie is definitely much better than the more traditional kind.

  41. […] the recipe, see my other blog, Diet, Dessert and Dogs. Posted by Ricki Filed in dairy free, egg free, fancy desserts, indulgent, pareve, pies and […]

  42. Susan Says:

    Carapace? There’s no “Fear Factor” here. I adore your offering for SHF, Ricki. Hard to get more decadent than flaky pastry filled with nuts and chocolate. Thanks so much for sharing.

  43. Hi Ricki,

    I just looked through this recipe and realize that it
    is, unfortunately, not truly gluten-free. I’m wondering if you need to reclassify certain of your recipes as ‘”wheat-free”, as opposed to “gluten-free”.

    As a celiac, I have to be absolutely vigilant about avoiding even a speck of gluten. Inadvertent ingestion causes absolutely terrible symptoms — anything from painful bloating and diarrhea to a profusely bleeding colon. Spelt flour is “wheat-free”, but it nonetheless contains gluten, as does barley-malt syrup. Here’s one of many sites that will confirm that Spelt is not gluten-free:

    Here’s a list of ‘avoid-at-all-cost” foodstuffs for celiacs:
    Wheat in all forms including spelt, kamut, triticale (a combination of wheat and rye), durum, einkorn, farina, semolina, cake flour, matzo (or matzah) and couscous.//Ingredients with “wheat” in the name including wheat starch, modified wheat starch, hydrolyzed wheat protein and pregelatinized wheat protein. (Buckwheat, which is gluten free, is an exception.)//Barley malt, which is usually made from barley, and malt syrup, malt extract, malt flavoring and malt vinegar.// Breaded or floured meat, poultry, seafood and vegetables. Also meat, poultry and vegetables when they have a sauce or marinade that contains gluten, such as soy and teriyaki sauces.// Licorice, imitation crab meat, beer, most is fermented from barley. (Specialty gluten-free beer is available from several companies.)//

    I hope this helps when you alert your readers to the content of your recipes.

    Have you experimented with buckwheat, teff, or rice flour?


  44. Ricki Says:


    I’m not sure where you see “gluten-free” on this recipe–it’s in the category “wheat-free,” but not “gluten-free.” I do know that spelt has gluten, and don’t classify my spelt-containing recipes as GF. The filling, however, is indeed GF, so if you have a favorite GF pie crust, you can use it in that. In the GF Recipe Index at right, I include the filling, but am sure to tell people to use a GF crust. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: